Shopping for a pre-owned vehicle involves more than just finding a good price—it’s about understanding long-term costs as well. From insurance and fuel to routine maintenance and unexpected repairs, the total cost of ownership plays a big role in choosing the right car. At AutoPark Barrie, we help buyers focus not just on affordability at purchase, but also on value and dependability over time.
If you’re in the market for a car that’s easy on your wallet both now and down the road, this guide outlines ten of the most affordable used vehicles to own and maintain. These models are recognized for their long-term reliability, efficiency, and lower repair costs—making them smart choices for everyday drivers, students, first-time buyers, and anyone looking to reduce monthly vehicle expenses.
For decades, the Toyota Corolla has been a top recommendation for anyone who values low operating costs and long-term dependability. Recent pre-owned Corolla models (from 2017 and newer) offer fuel economy around 7.0 L/100 km and a reputation for needing little more than regular oil changes and brake service. With widely available parts, excellent resale value, and consistently strong safety scores, the Corolla is a worry-free choice for budget-focused buyers.
Another Canadian favourite, the Honda Civic continues to dominate the compact car segment thanks to its blend of reliability and efficiency. Even older pre-owned Civics retain their value well and keep ownership costs low. Fuel economy for late-model Civics averages 6.5 to 7.0 L/100 km combined, and the vehicle’s track record for long-lasting components means fewer trips to the mechanic. Insurance rates are also generally favourable, making it a wise pick for young or first-time drivers.
Often found at a lower price point than its Japanese rivals, the Hyundai Elantra offers incredible value in the used vehicle market. Models from 2017 onward have improved quality, more advanced features, and excellent warranty coverage—some may even have portions of their 5-year/100,000 km powertrain warranty remaining. Real-world fuel economy hovers around 7.1 L/100 km, and maintenance costs are modest. Combined with a comfortable ride and modern tech, the Elantra makes a compelling argument for budget-conscious shoppers.
If you're looking for a car that’s reliable, efficient, and enjoyable to drive, the Mazda3 is a standout choice. Pre-owned models from the last generation benefit from Mazda’s SkyActiv technology, which boosts both fuel economy (6.8–7.2 L/100 km) and durability. Rust resistance has also improved significantly in newer models. Owners frequently praise the Mazda3 for its solid build quality and driving dynamics, while ongoing maintenance tends to be simple and affordable.
The Kia Forte has become an attractive pick for used car buyers who want modern features without high prices. From 2019 onward, Forte models come well-equipped with advanced safety technology, infotainment systems, and efficient 2.0L engines. Fuel economy averages around 7.3 L/100 km, and Kia’s generous warranty coverage (5 years/100,000 km from the original date) often means reduced repair costs for recent pre-owned vehicles. Add to that low insurance rates and affordable parts, and the Forte proves to be a smart financial choice.
Compact, reliable, and nearly indestructible, the pre-owned Toyota Yaris is a favourite among urban drivers and students. Despite being discontinued in 2020, used models remain readily available and are known for minimal repair needs. With a fuel consumption rating often below 6.5 L/100 km, and very few complex systems that could fail, the Yaris is one of the lowest-cost vehicles to keep on the road year after year.
The Honda Fit is another subcompact that punches above its weight in both reliability and practicality. It’s known for a surprisingly roomy cabin, clever interior storage, and a strong resale market. Fuel efficiency ranges between 6.5 and 6.9 L/100 km for most used models. The Fit also tends to age well, with many examples reaching high mileage with only routine maintenance. It’s a versatile option for those who want utility without higher ownership costs.
Pre-owned Chevrolet Spark models represent excellent value for buyers wanting a low-cost urban commuter. With small dimensions, high efficiency (around 6.2 L/100 km combined), and limited mechanical complexity, the Spark is inexpensive to own. Basic repairs and parts are relatively cheap, and insurance rates are among the lowest in the market. Its size may not suit every driver, but for those focused on budget and city travel, it’s hard to find better.
Offering more space than most subcompacts, the used Nissan Versa Note delivers impressive value. It provides generous cargo room, comfortable seating, and a simple, efficient 1.6L engine. Fuel consumption ranges between 6.7 and 7.1 L/100 km, depending on the trim and transmission. The Versa Note also benefits from Nissan’s reputation for long-term mechanical durability, and repairs tend to be straightforward and low in cost.
Rounding out our list is the pre-owned Mitsubishi Mirage—a small hatchback that delivers on affordability in nearly every category. With a lightweight frame, simple mechanical components, and excellent fuel economy (as low as 5.9 L/100 km combined), the Mirage is one of the least expensive vehicles to run and maintain. While performance and refinement are modest, its unbeatable efficiency and low repair costs make it a practical and strategic option for drivers prioritizing operating expenses.
At AutoPark Barrie, our inventory features a wide range of affordable, inspected used and pre-owned vehicles ideally suited for drivers who want to keep costs low without compromising on reliability or comfort. We understand that ownership cost is just as important as sticker price. That’s why we prioritize vehicles with proven reliability records and affordable upkeep when selecting our used vehicle stock.
Our team is here to walk you through ownership costs, provide transparent information, and help you find a car that fits your lifestyle and financial goals. Whether you're a student looking for your first vehicle, a commuter needing fuel efficiency, or simply looking to reduce your car expenses, we’ll help you choose the right option—backed by quality and value.
Final Thoughts
Owning a car doesn’t have to be expensive. By focusing on vehicles with excellent fuel economy, minimal maintenance needs, and long-term reliability, you can significantly reduce the cost of driving. Visit AutoPark Barrie today and discover affordable vehicles that fit your life—and your budget.
Other Articles That May Interest You
The Car Ownership Expenses to Keep in Mind When Planning Your Used Car Budget
Purchasing a used vehicle is a significant decision, and planning your budget properly is one of the most important steps in the process. At AutoPark Barrie, we understand that the price listed on the windshield is only part of the equation. A realistic and complete budget includes the ongoing costs of ownership—expenses that can vary widely depending on the vehicle, your lifestyle, and even...
The Best Used 2-Door Coupes for Summer in Ontario
When the warmer weather arrives and Ontario roads start to dry out, there's something undeniably appealing about driving a sleek, two-door coupe. Whether it's a winding country road or a late-night city cruise, coupes bring driving excitement that few other vehicles can match. At AutoPark Barrie, drivers looking for a pre-owned 2-door model have plenty of compelling options—ranging from...
What Do You Need to Buy a Pre-Owned Vehicle in Ontario?
Purchasing a pre-owned vehicle in Ontario is a significant decision that requires preparation, knowledge, and the right documentation. Whether you’re buying from a dealership or a private seller, understanding the process can help ensure a smooth and hassle-free experience. From necessary paperwork to financial considerations and insurance requirements, this guide provides everything you need...
